Your cart
Close Alternative Icon
FREE SHIPPING ON ALL ORDERS FREE SHIPPING ON ALL ORDERS
Close Icon
Down Arrow Icon
Arrow Thin Left Icon Arrow Thin Right Icon

    Dreaming of Montauk

    We'll all be back out soon, but until then...

    Shop New Arrivals Below

    Dreaming of Montauk

    We'll all be back out soon, but until then...

    Shop New Arrivals Below

    Dreaming of Montauk

    We'll all be back out soon, but until then...

    Shop New Arrivals Below

    Dreaming of Montauk

    We'll all be back out soon, but until then...

    Shop New Arrivals Below

    Dreaming of Montauk

    We'll all be back out soon, but until then...

    Shop New Arrivals Below
    Hope to see you

    Hope to see you

    We're not exactly sure when the doors will open this season, but we're staying positive and printing away so when the time comes, we'll be fully stocked and ready for you

    New Amagansett styles

    New Amagansett styles

    We'll be adding new Amagansett styles over the next couple weeks, so please check back soon or drop us a line with any requests.  hello@shopmainstay.com

    Store Locations

    MONTAUK MAINSTAY 

    725B Montauk Hwy.

    Montauk, NY 11954

    (631) 668-8117

    AMAGANSETT MAINSTAY 

    167 Main St.

    Amagansett, NY 11930

    (631) 527-7576

    GREENPORT MAINSTAY 

    15 Front St. 

    Greenport, NY 11944

    (631) 333-2111

    Arrow Thin Left Icon Arrow Thin Right Icon

      Before you go...

      A few things to look forward to